texts, fact sheets, and summaries
Media releases, news coverage, and announcements
#300 - 895 Fort Street
Victoria, BC, Canada
Tel: (250) 384-2776
Fax: (250) 389-0105
Substudy 14 Fact Sheet
Evaluation of the Cost-Effectiveness of the Quick Response Program
of Saskatoon District Health (NA101-14)
Saskatoon District Health
This project is one of fifteen sub-studies of the National Evaluation
of the Cost-Effectiveness of Home Care Project (NA101). People who come
to hospital emergency departments with non-acute conditions may be admitted
to hospital because there are no appropriate community-based alternatives,
or because they are either unaware of these alternatives, or unable to
access them. To fill this gap, Quick Response Programs (QRPs) are intended
to divert such people from hospitals to suitable community-based care.
Typically, QRPs can assess patients rapidly - usually within two hours
- and then refer them to other services. This evaluation project sought
to determine whether Saskatoon District Health's QRP has been successful
in decreasing hospital admissions for elderly non-acute patients, and
whether the program is cost-effective.
Quick Response Programs (QRPs) provide access for individuals to an alternate
care option that involves an interdisciplinary and multi-sectoral approach
to problem-solving, decision-making, and delivery of appropriate community-based
care from a variety of sources. Within Saskatoon District Health (SDH),
the QRP is modeled within a well-established, single-entry, case management
framework for community-based services, the Coordinated Assessment Unit
(CAU). QRPs arrange for additional care in the home as an alternative
for individuals who would normally be admitted to the hospital upon presentation
at the Emergency Departments (EDs) in Saskatoon.
The project leaders identified the following outcomes:
- Patients who accepted QRP services and then returned home received
a greater range and intensity of community-based services.
- The average total cost of community-based services for QRP patients
for 30 days was $358.
- Of 521 patients admitted to hospital as in-patients, only two were
subsequently determined to have been non-acute (i.e., comparable to
QRT clients). The total non-acute hospital care costs for the total
hospital stay for these individuals was $3,927.
- Forty-six patients were identified as multiple users of emergency
department services, with between four and 19 visits in the 11-week
period. Sixty-three per cent of those visits were found to have been
preventable, though not necessarily by services QRP could have initiated.
The project leaders indicated that their findings are important because,
in their view, this study suggests that Saskatoon District Health's QRP
can successfully identify non-acute patients, and secure access to appropriate
community-based care for them. However, although such services are considerably
cheaper than hospital-based care, this process will not decrease overall
expenditures unless corresponding numbers of hospital beds are eventually
The evaluation reviewed the charts of 2,343 elderly people who made a
total of 3,074 visits to the emergency departments of three Saskatoon
hospitals between September 27 and December 11, 1999. The level of acuity
for those who were admitted as in-patients was assessed using a standard
tool (InterQual® ISD-A). For those not admitted, data were collected
on community-based services provided to patients for 30 days before and
after the visit to emergency. For all the community-based services accessed
through the QRP, the cost of providing direct and indirect patient care
was calculated (including travel time). These costs were compared to the
in-patient costs of caring for patients who were admitted to the hospital,
but who could have been cared for by a community-based service.
HTF Contribution to the Project:
$1,505,000 (divided among the 15 sub-studies)
Language of Report: